Amazon has made some baffling changes to the way it handles personal documents emailed to a Kindle. On the plus side, we can now archive personal documents – Amazon is providing 5GB of storage in the cloud for this purpose.
However, the implementation I am seeing at the moment is really quite strange. I’m hoping it’s still a work in progress.
Shared send-to-device email address
Previously, if you had multiple Kindles registered to the same account, each Kindle had its own send-to-kindle email address. This made it very easy to choose which Kindle would receive the emailed document. Now, all Kindles have the same email address. The help page on
Associating Kindles to your Send-to-Kindle E-mail Address says:
“This Send-to-Kindle e-mail address is associated with your Amazon account and will be the e-mail address associated with all additional Kindle devices that you register to your account in the future” (my emphasis).
To test this, from the Manage Your Kindle page, I chose ‘Personal Document Settings’:

This showed the three Kindles associated with my account (a K3, a K2 and a DX). None of them had ‘Auto deliver’ set up as they had all been registered for quite some time. Following the instructions, I deregistered and then re-registered my K3. The personal document settings then looked like this:

Clicking on either of the ‘Edit’ options (marked in red) displayed this window:

Next, I bit the bullet and deregistered/re-registered my K2. After that, editing the Kindle e-mail address changed the address for both Kindles. The K2 was selected by default to receive documents sent to the shared address. I have disabled it in the screenshot below:

So, if I leave the options as above, anything I email will only go to my K3. But what if I want to send something to the K2 only? I have to go back to MYK, swap the ticks around, and then send the email. And if my son ever deregisters/re-registers his DX, he could suddenly start receiving my shopping lists, my work documents … and perhaps much worse
[Edit to add] Worse still, if you need to deregister/re-register a Kindle again, it ‘forgets’ the setting for that Kindle. As shown in the screenshot above, I had disabled my K2 from receiving emailed documents. I just now deregistered/re-registered the K2 – it’s now enabled:

Other unfortunate scenarios come readily to mind. What if I buy my granddaughter a new Kindle and register it to my account? It will silently and automatically be given the ‘master’ email address and be selected for auto deliver. But I am old and will forget this happens. My granddaughter may start receiving all manner of unsuitable and unwanted documents.
This new setup could be a very flexible addition if only each device could have its own email address and its own list of devices that would receive documents sent to that address.
Archiving
Archiving of personal documents is great, but it’s an all-or-nothing affair. If I have archiving turned on, that unsuitable document accidentally sent to my granddaughter’s hypothetical Kindle would still be in the archives after it is deleted from her Kindle, unless I remember to also delete it from the archives.
In practice, I want to archive only some things. I certainly don’t want to archive my shopping lists, transient work documents, or web pages sent to my Kindle, but I do want to archive books I have downloaded from, say, Gutenberg and emailed to my Kindle.
Wouldn’t it have been much easier to implement optional archiving by simply adding the option to use a subject line of ‘Archive’ (or ‘No archive’) to optionally archive personal documents? If the document is a pdf for conversion, a subject line of “convert archive” would not be difficult to parse.
As things stand at the moment, anyone with a variety of family members or friends on their account is going to have to be very mindful of who is going to receive each emailed document, and whether it will be archived. Some people may become very familiar with the ‘Personal Documents Settings’ page!
I’ve emailed kindle-feedback@amazon.com.
Tagged Kindle